BBQ Sauce: The Ultimate Guide

Avatar photo



Updated on

The barbecue sauce is an essential dish in any cook’s repertoire. It can give a great grilled steak or pulled pork an extra kick, even improving bland vegetables. There are indeed plenty of store-bought sauces to choose from, but nothing compares to the spice and freshness that comes from home cooking. 

If you want to make BBQ time enjoyable and more delicious, bbq sauce can be one of the dishes. But, first off, don’t forget that your BBQ sauce needs some sweetness, so feel free to add some sugar as well as salt. Secondly, you’ll need some vinegar as well as red pepper flakes—the best BBQ sauces balance sweet, salty, sour and spicy flavours. Let’s get started.

How to make BBQ sauce

No BBQ is complete without the perfect sauce. Making your barbecue sauce is inexpensive and easy, making it an excellent option for a frugal family. Let’s learn how to make BBQ sauce at home: 

Choose your ingredients

If you love barbeque sauce, the ingredients you choose to make it with can make a big difference in taste or texture.

Tomato Paste

A popular condiment that is frequently used for BBQ sauce is tomato paste. It contains the flavour of tomatoes, which are commonly used in barbecue sauce recipes. Tomato paste also adds thickness to the sauce, making it more appetizing and easier to use as a condiment for any meal. Some people may not know that tomato paste can be purchased in a tube form and will keep for up to one year on the shelf.


Then you have to mix light water because we will mix many more ingredients. And if you want to thin the sauce, you can add more water. Such as 2-3 cups.


Now you can mix the amount of sugar. You need to adjust according to your taste. If you like sweet sauces, you should increase the amount of sugar. But if you don’t like too much sweetness, reduce the amount of sugar. 


You can also add honey to make the sauce more delicious. The taste of honey tomato sauce is very tender with meat and chicken barbecue.


Vinegar is a crucial ingredient in many barbecue sauces. Vinegar is a natural preservative and helps to add flavour to the sauce. Plus, it’s gluten-free! It’s not expensive either; apple cider vinegar, white vinegar, or red wine vinegar will all do the trick. You can mix 1 cup of vinegar in tomato paste. And if you want an extra spicy taste, you can combine more.


Molasses is a great, natural sweetener for BBQ catsup that doesn’t have many calories and can be made from different plant-based sources. It is also perfect for those who are lactose intolerant. If you’re looking for something with a little bit of sweetness, try adding molasses into your homemade BBQ sauce recipe.

Worcestershire Sauce

Worcestershire sauce has been a mainstay for many households, but it’s an excellent ingredient for making barbecue sauce. The sauce is perfect for adding some depth and tang to your sauces or marinades with just a few tablespoons in any recipe. 

Smoked Paprika

Smoked paprika is a key ingredient in many different types of barbecue sauces. This spice has a delicate smoky flavour that you can’t replicate with any other element. However, if desired, it can be swapped out for ground chipotle or cayenne pepper. 


Salt is an essential ingredient in most BBQ catsup sauces. Salt enhances the flavours of the other ingredients and contrasts with the sugar, pepper, and vinegar in the sauce. It also helps to tenderize tough meats that are used for BBQ recipes.

Black pepper 

Believe it or not, black pepper is an ingredient that can be used to make sauce. Black pepper contains piperine, which gives it a bite and spiciness. The quality of the spiciness depends on the amount added and who produces the spice.

Onion Powder

The perfect barbecue sauce is not complete without onion powder. Onion powder provides a distinct flavour and is particularly good for barbecue sauces that do not contain tomatoes or wine. These ingredients can make the sauce too acidic.

Making Process of BBQ Sauce

Here’s how to make barbecue sauce by combining all the ingredients.

  1. Add all your ingredients to a bowl and mix well.
  2. Heat some oil in a pan over medium heat.
  3. Pour half of the mixture into the hot pan and stir until combined with the other half.
  4. Once mixed, add more oil to the pan if needed.
  5. Cook the ingredients mixer for about 5 minutes, constantly stirring not to burn any part of the sauce.
  6. Remove from heat once cooked through. 

How do you get smoke flavor in BBQ sauce?

Common ingredients to add a smoky flavor are ingredients like liquid smoke, molasses, Worcestershire sauce, soy sauce, chipotle peppers and liquid hickory. If you want the smoky flavor of sauce, there are several options for achieving it. After reading this article, you will be able to choose which one is right for you.

Adding liquid smoke is the most common way to get the smoky flavor into barbecue sauces. It can be added to any type of sauce, but is mixed with other ingredients differently depending on the type of sauce that it is mixed with. 

For example, if you mix barbecue sauce with tomato paste or ketchup, then adding liquid smoke would not work as well because these types of sauces already have some strong flavors from their base ingredients. If you add a lot of liquid smoke, though, they may become too overpowering and mask out all of your other flavors.

The best way to incorporate the taste of smoke into barbecue sauce is to use hickory or mesquite wood chips. These wood chips can be added during cooking, allowing the smoky flavor to permeate the food. 

Alternatively, the chips can be soaked in water for 20 minutes before adding them to the sauce. They can also be sprinkled on top of the sauce before serving.

Some FAQ regarding BBQ sauce

How do I know when my barbecue sauce is ready?

The best way to check whether it has reached its perfect consistency, taste, and aroma is to use a spoon to scoop out small amounts of the sauce onto a plate.

What should be added to my barbecue sauce?

You can add anything your heart desires! Some popular additions are onions, garlic, jalapenos or even fresh herbs like basil, oregano, thyme etc. 

Can I make this recipe in advance?

Yes, but keep in mind that if you leave the mixture too long before serving, it will lose some of its flavours. It’s better to cook it right away as soon as possible after making it. 

How do I store barbecue sauce?

Store sauce in an airtight container for up to 3 days. If refrigerated, they’ll last about one week. 

Does BBQ sauce go bad? 

No, it doesn’t get any worse than when you first made it, and it tastes just fine. However, if you’re not going to use it within a few weeks, then it might start losing its flavour. In which case, throw out what is left and buy more. 

Does BBQ sauce need to be refrigerated? 

Yes, but only until the day that you plan on using it. Refrigerating it too much can cause condensation inside your bottle or jar, so make sure there are no leaks. 

What should I look for when buying BBQ Sauce? 

Look at the ingredients list first before purchasing any product. If they have sugar as an ingredient, avoid those products. Also, check how long the manufacturer has been around. 

How long does BBQ sauce last?

The sauce shelf life is around 6 months. After opening the bottle, store it in its original container in the refrigerator where it will keep for weeks or even months longer. Use it within 8 months of opening, otherwise toss out.

How long does BBQ sauce last in the fridge?

The average shelf life of a sauce is about 6 months. If you can keep it properly in the fridge, its quality will remain intact. But I think it is better to finish the sauce in 6 months.


If you enjoy BBQ sauce and want to make it at home, the process is quite simple. All you need are a few ingredients and a few minutes of your time. Barbecue sauce has many variations, but the basic sauces are usually made of tomatoes, vinegar, sugar, salt, and spices. 

Different sauce recipes may have other ingredients, including Worcestershire sauce. If they are looking for a thicker texture, they may add cornstarch. The basting sauce is usually applied to the meat while cooking. 

Try adding chipotle peppers, smoked paprika, or liquid smoke extract if you enjoy smoky flavors. For more sweetness and tangy flavorings such as tomatoes, add tomato paste. Before beginning the cooking process, it is vital to have all ingredients ready. 

About The Author

Avatar photo

Reviewed by


James is a writer who is a self-confessed kitchenware and coffee nerd and a strong advocate of Sundays, good butter, and warm sourdough.